The Electoral Fee of South Africa (IEC) is holding a three-day convention to analyze the feasibility and desirability of an digital voting system for South Africa.
The convention, which began on Monday in Cape City, consists of audio system from a variety of nations, together with Estonia, Namibia and the Democratic Republic of Congo, which have already carried out e-voting programs. Their insights will inform the IEC’s determination making on whether or not or to not incorporate e-voting into South African elections.
E-voting presents a variety of advantages, together with improved entry for the aged and the disabled and people in residing in distant areas; a discount in human error within the dealing with of ballots; and a major discount in the price of working elections.
However there are probably harmful downsides to digitising the electoral course of that might undermine the integrity of South Africa’s democracy.
“The final word purpose of digital transformation ought to be to make sure that queues get shorter, not longer, on voting day,” mentioned house affairs minister Leon Schreiber, who spoke on the convention concerning the function the implementation of a digital ID system will play in making certain that an e-voting system might be much less vulnerable to identification fraud.
“The effectivity of any digital system ought to be higher, not worse, than the prevailing paper-based system. There may be frankly no level in digitalising a course of if it’ll be simply as sluggish, inefficient and insecure because the handbook, paper-based course of that preceded it,” mentioned Schreiber.
One of many areas the place South Africa’s handbook vote-counting system has benefits over e-voting is the quantity of visibility afforded to electoral officers. When elections are held, every voting station has officers from all events listed on the poll current the place the votes are counted, conserving all events trustworthy and serving to establish any irregularities shortly.
Visibility
Based on an IEC explainer on the counting course of, consequence slips are then signed by the counting officer, impartial candidate brokers and get together brokers. Outcomes are additionally verified independently by exterior auditors.
With an digital system, this visibility goes away, placing the ballots susceptible to being hacked remotely or being tampered with by any entity that has entry to the voting system – on the danger of nobody ever recognizing that fraud came about.
Due to this, some nations are towards digital voting. The German constitutional court docket in 2009 dominated that using digital voting machines was unconstitutional, citing the necessity for residents to have a course of that allowed for open scrutiny.
Learn: AI deepfakes and SA’s combat to guard the 2024 election
“All important steps [in the voting process] are topic to public scrutiny,” the court docket mentioned in a translated model of its ruling. “When utilizing digital voting machines, the important steps of the electoral act and the dedication of outcomes by the citizen can’t be made reliably and with out particular experience.”
A scarcity of public belief is one other barrier to the success of e-voting programs. India is a good instance of this, the place digital voting machines have been used for sure constituencies since way back to 1989 and step by step phased in till their first nationwide deployment in 2004. Regardless of widespread use, the system has acquired sharp criticism from political activists and most of the people, who argue it’s susceptible to hacking and has no verifiable paper path.
Some nations, like France, are tentatively deploying e-voting, having used for the expertise for residents residing overseas with out adopting it for nationwide elections for concern of manipulation. The Netherlands was an early adopter of e-voting within the early 2000s however discontinued its use in 2008 after safety consultants efficiently demonstrated vulnerabilities within the system.
One of many causes the IEC is investigating e-voting programs is the hope that simpler entry may assist enhance voter turnout and thereby bolster citizen participation within the electoral course of and strengthen South Africa’s democracy within the course of. However an digital voting system will not be the one strategy to obtain this purpose.
Learn: IEC outcomes portal goes clean in obvious glitch
“Declining voter turnout and growing radicalism, together with from those that search to query the result of official elections, are warning indicators that we should do extra to reinforce public belief in democracy. In the end, it have to be the purpose of reform – digital or in any other case – to ship a greater expertise to the top person if we’re to guard the credibility and legitimacy of our elections,” mentioned Schreiber. – © 2025 NewsCentral Media
Get breaking information from TechCentral on WhatsApp. Enroll right here
